Russia bombed location in Syria near where US troops were present

(CNN)US troops were present when Russian warplanes bombed US backed anti-ISIS fighters in Syria on Saturday, two US officials told CNN, highlighting how close the two countries came to a major international incident.
A team of US Special Operations Forces were advising US-backed Syrian Democratic Forces at the location the Russians struck in Deir Ezzor in eastern Syria, one US official said.
    US personnel were "at most a couple of miles" away from the where the bomb landed, the official added.
    The US troops provided medical care to members of the Syrian Democratic Forces that were wounded in the airstrike, an image of which was tweeted out by the coalition.
    The US is still looking at the possibility the strike so close to US troops, and the SDF fighters it supports, may have been an error by the Russian pilot or a bomb that went astray rather than a deliberate attack on US troops by the Russians, the US official said.
    Regardless of the circumstances of the strike, several US officials tell CNN it underscores the risk faced by having Russian, Syrian regime, US and US-backed fighters operating in extremely close proximity in eastern Syria.
    The US-led coalition fighting ISIS, Operation Inherent Resolve, issued a statement Saturday saying "Russian munitions impacted a location known to the Russians to contain Syrian Democratic Forces and coalition advisers."
    A coalition official told CNN that the coalition denied a Russian military request to strike an area in the province of Deir Ezzor, as there were coalition advisers and US-backed Syrian forces there. But the Russians decided to carry out the strike anyway.

    Russian Defense Ministry officials denied the Pentagon's charge Sunday, saying the airstrikes were directed at ISIS targets, according to state-run news agency TASS.
    "The Russian Aerospace Force inflict pinpoint strikes only on targets, confirmed through multiple channels, in the districts controlled by IS," ministry spokesman Igor Konashenkov said.
    He added that Russian command "notified in advance the US counterparts about borders of the military operation" in Deir Ezzor.
    The incident sparked high level discussions Sunday between US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov, as well as a phone call between the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Gen. Joseph Dunford and his Russian counterpart Gen. Valery Gerasimov, the Russian Chief of General Staff.
    Coalition officials have said that the recent increased proximity between Russian-backed regime troops and coalition-backed Syrian Democratic Forces has necessitated increased "de-confliction" between the Russian and coalition militaries.
    "The convergence of military forces in this area calls for increased awareness and de-confliction," coalition spokesman US Army Col. Ryan Dillon told reporters last week, referring to the regime and SDF offensives in Deir Ezzor province.
    While regime forces had primarily operated on the western side of the Euphrates River and SDF forces on the eastern side, the Russian Ministry of Defense issued a statement Monday saying Syrian regime troops, backed by Russian airpower, had crossed over to the river's eastern bank near Deir Ezzor city.
    But with Russian and coalition military officers already using the communications hotline that allows the two sides to de-conflict their respective forces on a daily basis, it is difficult to imagine how such efforts can be increased.
    "Coalition officials are available and the de-confliction line with Russia is open 24 hours per day," Coalition commander Lt. Gen. Paul E. Funk said in a statement following Saturday's strike.
    "We put our full efforts into preventing unnecessary escalation among forces that share ISIS as our common enemy," Funk added.
    A US official told CNN that the intent was to shift the de-confliction conversations and focus them to be more tactical, sharing where ground forces were located to prevent any accidental targeting.
    And while coalition officials had recently trumpeted de-confliction efforts with Russia, Saturday's incident appeared to cast doubt on their effectiveness.
    _____________________________________________________________
    Citation
    Starr, Barbara, and Ryan Browne. “Russia Bombed Location in Syria near Where US Troops Were Present.” CNN, Cable News Network, 18 Sept. 2017, <edition.cnn.com/2017/09/18/politics/russia-us-syria-bomb-deir-ezzor/index.html>.
    _____________________________________________________________
    Response
    As a US based organization CNN primarily targets US citizens as their audience and with this piece expressing the tensions between the United States and Russia it seems probable that the intended audience of this article is white liberalists in the United States.
    I think that the bias of the organization and of the author of this article is quite evident because it is well known that there is tension between Russia and the US. The wording of the article title plays off of these tensions making it sound as if Russia is intentionally inciting the US and is deliberately antagonizing the troops that are placed in Syria. As the article expresses the information about the bombing it continually presents and supports the supposition that Russia was intentionally causing trouble while only once mentioning that it may have been an accident and not supporting or delving deeper into that possibility at all. This is clearly purposed to slant the opinions of the readers presenting only the information that CNN thinks their readers will want to hear.
    I definitely agree with this article that the bombing that occurred so close to US troops does seem suspicious and should definitely cause the US to be wary in the future as they weigh in Russia's unpredictability, for lack of a better word. However, I do not know that we can immediately assume that this is a direct attack against the US like the article seems to be implying. The article does mention briefly that it is possible that a Russian pilot made a mistake, and I would argue that we should give Russia the benefit of the doubt on this one and not just write Russia off for their perceived malevolence.

    Comments

    Post a Comment

    Popular posts from this blog

    South Korea, China seek to med relations after THAAD fallout

    SEOUL/BEIJING (Reuters) - South Korea and China have agreed to work swiftly to get their relations back on track following a year-long standoff over the deployment of a controversial U.S. anti-missile system in South Korea. A Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (THAAD) interceptor is launched during a successful intercept test, in this undated handout photo provided by the U.S. Department of Defense, Missile Defense Agency. REUTERS/U.S. Department of Defense, Missile Defense Agency/Handout via Reuters The installation of the U.S. Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (THAAD) system had angered China and spilled over into trade, hurting South Korean business interests in the country. China believed the system’s powerful radar could be used to look inside its territory. South Korea and the United States have repeatedly said THAAD only serves to defend against the growing missile threat from North Korea. “Both sides shared the view that the strengthening of exchange and cooperatio...
    Read more

    About Me

    Image
    My name is Nathan Daubenmier. I am the fourth child in a family of nine (seven children). I spent the first 12 years of my life living in a typical modest home in America but even before I turned seven years old the edges of my horizon were being broadened as we adopted three children from Ethiopia into our home. With them came a little taste of Africa that proved to be irresistible to my parents and at the age of 12 my family moved to Kenya where we are still living. We are living at a boarding school for the children of missionaries throughout Africa and one of the biggest benefits I have gained from living here is the access to so many cultures. I have had the immense opportunity to interact with people of all sorts of nations and races and this has profoundly impacted my world view and how I interpret everything around me. I am proud to be a Christian and third culture kid living in Kenya and I would not give up the experiences I have had in the past several years here for anythin...
    Read more

    Defective North Korean soldier in critical condition; U.N. investigating

    SEOUL (Reuters) - A North Korean soldier shot while defecting to the South has undergone several surgical procedures and is in a critical condition, South Korea’s government and military said on Tuesday, with doctors expecting to save him. “Until this morning, we heard he had no consciousness and was unable to breathe on his own but his life can be saved,” said Suh Wook, chief director of operations at South Korea’s Joint Chiefs of Staff, who was briefing lawmakers regarding Monday’s event. Five bullets had been extracted from the soldier’s body so far, leaving an estimated two inside, Suh added. Lee Cook-jong, the surgeon in charge of the soldier’s treatment, told reporters earlier on Tuesday his condition was critical due to intestinal damage caused by the bullets. The soldier had sped towards the border in a vehicle when a wheel came loose, forcing him to escape on foot under fire from four North Korean soldiers who shot around 40 rounds at him, Suh said. North Korea’s m...
    Read more